Dead Blondes Episode 2: Thelma Todd
A few observations:
The program resembles a number of other accounts, not surprisingly as the author consulted a number of other works including this blog, which is listed as one of the sources. But what has been repeated in other accounts is not always correct. Sometimes they keep a story going only because it has been told before, and not because it was correct.
The "unusual clause" about Thelma Todd being thin was not really unusual as they made all the girls get skinny. It was considered an important enough problem that a series of articles was written about it in PHOTOPLAY magazine.
Thelma Todd at the Roach studio didn't predate Jean Harlow's fame as Jean Harlow became a big star in HELL'S ANGELS, and Thelma Todd actually came to work for Hal Roach after Jean Harlow had left his employ.
Says Roland West was one of the most "respected" of film makers: I would have said he was regarded as one of the most eccentric.
A "Mistress" is a kept woman: Roland West didn't support Thelma Todd financially. Although Jewel Carmen was called Roland West's "wife", Donati has said the two don't actually seem to have been married, in which case Roland West was simply involved with more than one woman rather than being married to one and having another one on the side.
Accident theory repeatedly called "eminently reasonable" while discussing Roland West: not everyone thought so well of it at the time. That theory was criticized for assuming that Thelma Todd didn't know of the dangers of carbon monoxide while it's dangers were well known and had been covered in the news.*
The impression is given that the Mafia was linked to the case because of something Roland West said: actually the gangsters had been mentioned earlier in the investigation.
The Grand Jury investigation did not reach a conclusion as stated. The case actually ended with a hung jury. The jurors were split between the suicide and murder theories, with none of them believing that it had been an accident.
Pat DeCicco said to have "no" ties to the Mafia: he at very least was associated with people with known underworld connections, such as George Raft.**
Roland West was retired and did not have his career ended by scandal as has frequently been said.
DA's office said to have tried to drag out the investigation: usually the story is that they wanted to get it over as quickly as possible. and that they had a history of doing that.
Some people call everything "forgotten", which seems kind of odd. Obviously somebody remembered it in order to make the program. "Obscure" seems more appropriate.